When Do Landlord-Tenant Disputes Become a Matter of Civil Litigation?

What To Do When a Landlord-Tenant Dispute Becomes a Matter of Civil Litigation

When a landlord and tenant enter into a rental agreement, both sides have legally binding rights and obligations. While most tenancies run smoothly, conflicts can occasionally arise, ranging from minor misunderstandings to major disagreements that require legal intervention.

Navigating the complexities of such disputes demands a clear understanding of the legal framework, the rights and responsibilities of each party, and the pathways available for resolution. In this article, we explore the legal rights of landlord-tenant disputes, common causes of disputes, and the steps toward resolution. 

Legal Rights and Obligations of Tenants and Landlords in the UK

In the UK, tenants and landlords in the private rented sector have distinct rights and responsibilities, critical for maintaining a lawful and fair housing system.

For Tenants:

  • Pay Rent on Time: Rent should be paid in advance, and failure to do so may lead to legal eviction steps by the landlord.
  • Pay Bills: Tenants are responsible for paying bills like council tax and utilities per the tenancy agreement.
  • Property Upkeep: Tenants must keep the property clean, ventilated, and undertake minor maintenance like smoke alarm checks.
  • Neighbourly Conduct: Tenants should act considerately towards neighbours to avoid eviction for anti-social behaviour.
  • Lodging Rules: Sub-letting or taking in lodgers is prohibited without the landlord’s permission.
  • Appliance Operation: Tenants should understand how to operate appliances and know the location of the stopcock, fuse box, and meters.
  • Report Repairs: Any needed repairs should be reported to the landlord or agent for action.

For Landlords:

  • Documentation: Provide tenants with ‘start of tenancy’ paperwork, including safety certificates and deposit protection information.
  • Maintenance: Maintain the property’s exterior and structure in proper condition.
  • Safety Checks: Ensure carbon monoxide and smoke alarms are set up and working.
  • Repair Handling: Address issues with water, electricity, and gas supply promptly.
  • Gas Safety: Arrange annual gas safety checks for any gas appliances.
  • Notice for Visits: Provide at least 24 hours notice for any visits to the property for activities like repairs.
  • Licensing: Obtain the necessary licenses for houses in multiple occupations (HMOs) as needed.
  • Energy Performance: Meet the minimum Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) requirements, with all properties let on new tenancies needing at least an EPC Band E.

These guidelines are designed to help landlords and tenants understand their roles, maintain high standards, and foster professional, positive relationships.

Common Causes of Landlord-Tenant Disputes

Landlord-tenant relationships can be complex, and disputes are not uncommon. Understanding these common causes can help both parties address potential conflicts effectively.

  1. Late Payment of Rent: A primary cause of dispute is late rent payments. Tenants may delay or withhold rent due to financial difficulties or as leverage in other disagreements with the landlord. This situation often necessitates dispute resolution efforts to prevent escalation.
  2. Property Damage: Disagreements regarding who is accountable for property damage are common. The challenge here is distinguishing between normal wear and tear and damage caused by tenant actions, which can lead to litigation if not resolved.
  3. Property Repairs: Issues with property maintenance, such as leaking roofs or electrical problems, can lead to disputes, especially if the landlord delays or ignores necessary repairs. 
  4. Dilapidations: In commercial leases, tenant alterations can cause disputes, particularly regarding the property’s condition at the lease’s end. 
  5. Notices to Tenants: Disputes can arise from improperly served notices, whether due to incorrect wording or delivery method. Misunderstandings here often lead to legal advice being sought by either party.
  6. Insurance Cover: Disagreements over insurance, particularly if the landlord chooses a costly provider, can strain relations. Tenants may challenge these costs, leading to litigation in some cases.
  7. Service Charges: Tenants may dispute service charges, especially if they believe the costs are inflated or misallocated. Such disputes may escalate to court proceedings if not addressed through alternative dispute resolution methods.
  8. Causing a Nuisance: Tenant activities causing annoyances like noise or smells can trigger disputes. These situations often require legal intervention, potentially leading to court orders or eviction.
  9. Lease Assignment: Problems can occur when a tenant assigns their lease to a financially unstable new tenant, leading to landlord reluctance and potential litigation.
  10. Pets at Home: Disputes over pets, especially if tenants acquire pets contrary to the lease terms, may require litigation, and it can escalate to eviction if not resolved through negotiation.

What Should Be the Initial Step To Solve Landlord and Tenant Disputes?

The first step in resolving disputes between landlords and tenants should always be to attempt informal negotiations. This approach encourages both parties to reach a compromise and maintain a positive relationship and often leads to a quicker, less adversarial resolution.

If a compromise cannot be reached through direct discussion, seeking legal advice early becomes crucial. Consulting with experienced solicitors can help you understand your legal rights and strengthen your negotiation position. If these initial attempts fail, the claimant should consider escalating the dispute to a tenancy tribunal, which serves as a formal resolution mechanism.

Engaging with legal experts at an early stage ensures you are fully informed and prepared for effective negotiation, litigation, or any other legal remedies. 

What To Do When a Landlord-Tenant Dispute Becomes a Matter of Civil Litigation

When a landlord-tenant dispute cannot be settled through direct communication or negotiation, it may require civil litigation. 

First, both parties should engage in a dialogue to talk about the matter. This could involve meetings or informal negotiations to outline each party’s concerns and seek a mutual understanding or solution.

If initial talks don’t yield a resolution, the claimant should compose a detailed formal letter to the tenant or landlord. This letter should clearly state the problems, the potential consequences, and a call to action for resolving the dispute. It serves as a documented attempt at resolution and could be crucial if the case goes to court.

Before going to the court, parties may try mediation. It is a form of alternative dispute resolution where an impartial third party (litigant) helps both sides reach a voluntary agreement. It’s less formal than court and can provide a more amicable, cost-effective, and quicker resolution than litigation.

When all other avenues have been exhausted, the affected party may initiate legal proceedings. In the event of a trial, both the claimant and the defendant will articulate their positions, provide witness statements, and present supporting evidence. Upon reviewing all submitted materials, the judge will make a decision and establish a legally binding court order.

Throughout the litigation process, it is essential for both landlords and tenants to understand their legal rights and obligations, follow the civil procedure rules diligently, and consider legal representation to effectively present their case and navigate the complexities of the judicial system.

How Gulbenkian Andonian Solicitors Can Help

Facing a landlord-tenant dispute? Get help from Gulbenkian Andonian Solicitors.

As a renowned firm with a wealth of expertise in UK civil litigation law and dispute resolution, our legal experts are ready to provide you with the comprehensive legal advice and robust representation you need. We understand the complexities of property disputes and are committed to achieving the best possible outcomes for our clients.

Contact Gulbenkian Andonian Solicitors today for expert guidance throughout the process. Our team is ready to safeguard your interests and provide the support you need to confidently manage your case.


It is advisable to seek the assistance of a litigation solicitor when you are involved in a substantial dispute with another party and you require legal advice and representation in court proceedings or alternative dispute resolution.

The pre-action protocol abstracts the preliminary measures parties should take prior to initiating formal litigation. Its purpose is to facilitate the early sharing of relevant information, clarify the points of argument, and resolve disputes without resorting to court intervention.

Disclosure in a civil claim involves a formal procedure where each party submits a list of documents pertinent to the case’s key issues. Following this, they should facilitate the inspection of these materials by the opposing party unless there’s a legitimate legal reason or obligation to withhold such inspection.

A small claim refers to a legal claim that falls within the small claims track and is usually of lesser monetary value. Small claims are generally processed through a simpler, faster, and less formal court procedure.

The court fee for filing a claim in civil litigation varies depending on the claim’s value and the type of claim being filed. It is essential to understand the applicable court fees before initiating court proceedings.

Our law firm has a distinguished reputation in civil litigation, particularly in commercial disputes, the process of suing a company, housing issues, real estate disputes, employment law, as well as in complex matters involving immigration law, family disputes, and intellectual property rights.


Ask our Expert Legal Team

At Gulbenkian Andonian, we pride ourselves on “Excellence, Experience and Efficiency”. With over 35 years of experience on your side, our team of London based lawyers and solicitors have a wealth of experience advising individuals, families and businesses of all sizes to find clarity on UK law.

Call us on +44 (0) 207 269 9590 or fill out the form below. We usually reply within a few hours.

    Share This Post


    Neither Gulbenkian Andonian Solicitors ltd, nor their employees, agents, consultants or assignees, accept any liability based on the contents of written articles which are meant for guidance only and not as legal advice. We advise all readers to take professional advice before acting. If you would like to consult with a professional lawyer or solicitor to discuss your case, please do not hesitate to contact us directly. This site uses reCAPTCHA and is protected by the Google privacy policy and terms of service.